Reverse Mortgage vs Home Equity Loans (HELOC) – What’s the Smarter Choice?

July 23, 2021 By Michael Branson 9 comments

A Look into the “Reverse Mortgage” VS “HELOC” (Home Equity Line of Credit)

You may have heard of reverse mortgages, and the retirement option they can offer to individuals or couples who are “house rich, cash poor.”

For those looking to tap into their home equity in retirement, a reverse mortgage can be a useful tool to allow this. A home equity line of credit (HELOC) may be another option.

What you may not know about Reverse Mortgages

There’s a lot more to be gained by getting a reverse mortgage in 2021. With new product rules in place, as well as longtime, little-known benefits, a reverse mortgage is positioned as a better option than a HELOC in many cases.

Rather than simply allowing interest to grow on the reverse mortgage loan to be paid off when the loan comes due, reverse mortgage holders can actually make payments toward the loan.

This allows them not only to keep the interest balance down, but to enjoy a growing credit line that expands over time.

With a Reverse Mortgage You Can Also Make Repayments

A reverse mortgage is a loan, and like most loans, it comes with required interest. Unlike most loans, that interest does not need to be paid until the loan comes due—typically when the borrower moves from the home or passes away.

Qualifying borrowers who are 62 or older can receive payments from their home equity under a choice of payment plans, or they can opt to take the reverse mortgage in the form of a line of credit.

But borrowers have another choice: whether to pay the interest before it’s due.

It may not be an intuitive option, but it can make a major difference in the potential benefit of your home equity when compared to a home equity line of credit.

Reverse Mortgage vs Home Equity Loan Examples

Scenario 1. Jack takes home equity line of credit at age 70. He has a $300,000 home and no existing mortgage.

The following approximations are possible for Jack’s HELOC:

Jack can get up to $240,000 loan amount (up to 80% loan-to-value)
Jack decides to borrow $100,000 from his available line
Interest Rate: Prime + 2.00% amortized over 25 years, or roughly 5.50%
Mandatory monthly repayment would be $458/interest only or $614/fully amortized
Rate can change monthly
Closing costs: $0.00

Scenario 2: Jack takes a reverse mortgage as a line of credit at age 70. He has a $300,000 home and no existing mortgage.

He can opt to repay the interest over time, making monthly payments toward that interest, or simply defer the interest due to repay at a later time.

The following approximations are possible for Jack’s reverse mortgage line of credit:

Closing costs: $0.00
Jack can get up to $172,000 loan amount (up to 57% loan-to-value)
Jack decides to borrow $100,000 from his available line
Interest Rate: 1-year annual libor +2.75% – 5.1% fully indexed
If Jack “wanted to” he could make a monthly repayment to the interest only of $425 or choose to make any additional repayment to the principle
Rate can only change 1 time per year

Reverse Mortgages Offer a Unique Credit Line Growth Feature

Despite being able to borrow a larger amount under the home equity line of credit, he may actually be better off in the reverse mortgage line of credit scenario for several reasons.

First, Jack is making use of the credit line growth feature that Home Equity Conversion Mortgages (HECM) offer.

If a reverse mortgage credit line is left untouched, the untouched portion will actually grow over time, allowing the borrower to access more home equity in the long run.

This can be a wiser option, particularly for borrowers who are younger, just meeting the qualifying age of 62. In fact, many financial planners today are advising the use of a reverse mortgage credit line in this way.

Reverse mortgages also have new rules including a financial assessment to help ensure borrowers can meet their loan requirements. Research shows that retirees who use a reverse mortgage line of credit under this credit line options are less likely to run out of money in retirement than those who do not.

The line of credit, kept as a “rainy day fund,” or simply as another “bucket” of money to draw from and replenish, is a proven strategy and is gaining appeal in 2016.

Relaxed Qualifications

Under the reverse mortgage, there is no necessary monthly repayment, versus the home equity line of credit that requires ongoing repayment.

The reverse mortgage also may offer lighter qualifications, especially if the borrower has no existing mortgage and has a strong financial history.

The loan amount offered by a reverse mortgage line of credit may also be more appropriate for older borrowers, who would like to free up some additional cash flow, but may not be prepared to borrow (and repay) a large sum as made available by a HELOC option.

HELOC vs Reverse Mortgage Product Comparison

Compare Features	Traditional Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC)	Home Equity Conversion Mortgage (HECM)	Proprietary Reverse Mortgage (Non-FHA)
Borrower Minimum Age	18	62	55
Line of Credit Term	10 Years	Lifetime	10 Years
May Be Frozen	Yes*	No*	Yes*
Line of Credit Growth Rate	No	For Life	7 Years
$0 Monthly Payment Option	No	Yes	Yes
Income Requirements	Yes	Limited	Limited
Credit Score	680+	Any	Any
Reserves	2-6 Months PITI	Any	Any
Low/No Closing Costs	No	No	Yes
Fixed Interest Rate	No	No	No
Common Index	Prime Rate	Treasury	Treasury

*HELOC loans generally permit lenders to freeze or reduce a credit line if the value of the home declines significantly. You must be prepared to make this “balloon payment” by refinancing by obtaining a loan from another lender, or by some other means. If you are unable to make the balloon payment, you could lose your home.
Source: https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/201204_CFPB_HELOC-brochure.pdf

**All line of credit programs may be frozen if you fail to maintain taxes and insurance, or leave your home as your primary residence. If you enter bankruptcy, courts will not allow you to incur new debt while in BK proceedings and therefore your line of credit during this time could also be frozen.

HECM vs HELOC FAQs

What is the difference between a reverse mortgage and HELOC?

A HELOC is a line of credit that requires monthly payments and can be closed at any time the lender chooses. The reverse mortgage is insured and guaranteed to be available under the terms of the loan by HUD and the borrower is not required to make monthly repayments for as long as he/she lives in the home and pay the taxes and insurance in a timely manner.

Which is better Home Equity Line of Credit or Reverse Mortgage?

What is better is what is better for your circumstances. A HELOC is typically less expensive to establish but requires you to make monthly payments and failure to do so can hurt your credit and end in foreclosure. A reverse mortgage allows you to make payments if you want, but none are required and therefore you never have to sorry about months where your income may be less, but it does cost more to establish.

What makes a reverse mortgage line of credit a better option?

The reverse mortgage line of credit grows over time on the unused portion of the line. Not only can it not be closed by the lender, but the amount available to borrowers increases over time if you do not use all the funds available to you early in the term of the loan (HELOCS can be closed at any time the lender desires, even if you were depending on the availability of the funds).

What are the disadvantages of a reverse mortgage line of credit?

The disadvantage of a reverse mortgage is that it costs more to establish and if you want to pass the house down as a large inheritance and do not think you can make payments on the reverse mortgage, the asset you would pass would be less (however, this would also mean you should not get a HELOC either).

Are the qualifications different for reverse mortgages vs HELOC’s?

The qualifications are different for HELOC’s and reverse mortgages in that reverse mortgages use a residual income method of qualification vs the HELOC using an ability to repay method. The residual income method looks at all the borrower’s outgoing debts subtracted from their income and the borrower must have a minimum amount left on which to live each month. The ability to repay considers the borrowers debts as a ratio of the borrower’s total income to determine the borrower’s ability to repay the obligation. The residual income method employed by HUD for the reverse mortgage is much easier to qualify for most borrowers, especially those on fixed incomes.

ARLO recommends these helpful resources:

America's #1 Rated Reverse Lender Celebrating 17 Years of Excellence.

TALK TO OUR HUMAN EXPERTS TOLL FREE: 800-565-1722

LAUNCH ARLO CALCULATOR

About the Author, Michael G. Branson | Mike@allreverse.com

Michael G. Branson CEO, All Reverse Mortgage, Inc. and moderator of ARLO™ has 40 years of experience in the mortgage banking industry. He has devoted the past 17 years to reverse mortgages exclusively.

9 Comments on this Article

Dan C.
June 30th, 2022

Hi Arlo,

I understand that the amount of the current loan, the appraised value of the property and the "full assessment of the borrower's situation come into play:

1. Is there a percentage number between the appraised value of the property vs. the amount of the loan allowed come into play?
2. Does the credit worthiness of the applicant come into play?
Reply to Dan
- ARLO™
  July 6th, 2022
  
  Hello Dan,
  
  I am not sure I fully understand your question so forgive me if I answer from a different perspective but I will give it my best effort. A reverse mortgage is not like a traditional forward loan in the sense that an underwriter of a traditional forward loan may look at the borrower's qualifications and if he/she feels that the borrower is not qualified enough for the requested loan amount, they may approve the loan at a reduced amount.
  With a reverse mortgage, the borrower receives a benefit or loan eligibility based on the property value, loan program, the borrower's age and then it is a matter of whether or not the borrower and property qualify under the HUD and lender's requirements. The underwriter cannot reduce the loan eligibility by 5 - 10% and offer the borrower a lower loan amount if the borrower does not meet HUD's or the lender's normal requirements. The amount a borrower receives with a reverse mortgage is still determined by the borrower's age, the value of the home and the interest rates in effect.
  The older the borrower, the higher the percentage of the home's value (up to the maximum HUD lending limit) the borrower will receive under the program. The higher interest rate, the less the borrower will receive. This is why lender's use a reverse mortgage calculator based on the HUD calculations. HUD posts their Principal Limit Factor Tables on their website at https://www.hud.gov/program_offices/housing/sfh/hecm. To see what you can expect for your age, you need to be sure to use the age of the youngest borrower, the expected rate (not the initial rate if it is an adjustable-rate loan) and the value will be the appraised value or HUD lending limit (which is currently $970,800), whichever is less.
  
  HUD does have the ability to use a set-aside to pay the taxes and insurance on the property under certain circumstances that are laid out in their financial assessment guidelines that will help some borrowers that might have otherwise been declined due to certain credit history issues or those who are short of the residual cash requirement, but you would need to speak with your lender to determine if that would work for your circumstances.
  Prior to 2014, the credit of a reverse mortgage borrower was not a factor in the underwriting of the loan but the program came under intense scrutiny by congress due to the substantial losses it was experiencing. Even with no mortgage payments, borrowers were defaulting at a very high rate on taxes and insurance and the losses were endangering the Mortgage Insurance Premium (MIP) fund.
  HUD needed to take steps to shore up the program and some in Congress were calling for the elimination of the reverse mortgage program to protect the MIP fund. In 2015 HUD implemented the financial assessment guidelines they announced at the end of 2014 which now requires lenders to take the credit worthiness of the borrowers into consideration for reverse mortgages.
  Reply to ARLO
Ron
January 29th, 2020

I have a line of credit reverse mortgage balance. If I refinance how that would affect the line of credit. We are 65 now, could we get a higher percent of the property value?
Reply to Ron
- ARLO™
  January 30th, 2020
  
  Hello Ron,
  If you choose to refinance your current loan, the balance owed would be repaid with the new reverse mortgage. Any unused portion of the line would not be part of that pay off because you don't have to repay what you didn't borrow.
  So basically, the entire motivation for a refinance would have to be measured based on your current benefits as determined by current circumstances. Those circumstances are your ages, current interest rates and HUD guidelines in effect when you look at the refinance.
  Some borrowers would benefit greatly from a refinance who had higher interest rates and whose property values have increased and might also be under HUD's old parameters where the MIP renewal is 1.25% instead of the current .50%.
  However, you have to remember that you are going to pay the difference between the up-front mortgage insurance premium (UFMIP) that you paid on the initial loan and what the UFMIP would be at the higher value and HUD's current initial rate which is higher than it was years ago.
  Basically you would need to visit our HECM refinance calculator and see what your benefits would be above and beyond the amount left in your current line of credit to determine the actual benefit of a refinance under today's HUD parameters.
  Remember, lenders can't even do a refinance unless your loan meets certain conditions such as you are receiving adequate additional funds and it has been at least 18 months since your last loan. In any case, it probably wouldn't hurt to check if you believe you would receive more money under the refinance at this time (a lower interest rate alone is not a large enough benefit in HUD's opinion to lose funds or pay additional costs to refinance).
  Reply to ARLO
James L.
October 15th, 2019

I started out with a reverse mortgage, went to a regular mortgage. Can I go back to a reverse mortgage?
Reply to James
- ARLO™
  October 15th, 2019
  
  Hello James,
  
  As long as you do not have an existing reverse mortgage, you qualify for the loan under the current program parameters (you live in the home, your income and credit qualify and the property still meets HUD's minimum requirements) and your last loan did not result in an unpaid loss to HUD, you can certainly get another loan on this property or another if you move at this time.
  Reply to ARLO
Adrienne
April 9th, 2019

I have a high equity position in my property, will an inside appraisal be needed for a HELOC?
Reply to Adrienne
- ARLO™
  April 9th, 2019
  
  Hello Adrienne,
  
  I can tell you that for a Home Equity Conversion Mortgage or HECM reverse mortgage, the lender would require a full appraisal which would include an inspection of the interior of the property. But because we do not originate HELOC loans, I honestly cannot tell you every bank's requirements for the loans.
  The last several borrower with whom I have spoken who had obtained HELOC loans recently all indicated that they were required to have full appraisals performed of their homes which included interior inspections, but I don't know if that was because of the loan amount, the loan to value or if it is now a policy for all Home Equity Line of Credit loans. I am afraid you would have to speak with the lenders who offer this product to get this information.
  Reply to ARLO
Jason Wheeler
May 11th, 2016

Great blog. I feel like Reverse Mortgages really get a bad wrap by financial planners and consumers. They surely are NOT for everyone but with a really good loan officer like obviously you are, Senior should take a close look at what Reverse Mortgages offer and evaluate the costs based on their retirement goals.

Thanks for the perspective Mike!
Reply to Jason

America’s #1 rated reverse mortgage lender

Did You Know?

Your Home's Value

Age Matters

Great News! Your ARLO™ analysis is ready